Skip to main content
Sister Publication Links
  • European Rubber Journal
  • Plastics News
web
Subscribe
  • Login
  • Register
  • Subscribe
  • News
    • ITEC
    • Automotive
    • Tire
    • Non-Tire
    • Suppliers
    • Silicone
    • Latex
    • Coronavirus
    • Executive Action
    • Government/Legal
    • Opinion
    • Technical Notebooks
    • International Elastomer Show
    • Women in Tire & Rubber
    • HEXPOL Sponsored Content
    • Goodyear recognized by Lockheed Martin as 'elite supplier'
      EV tire advancements to help secure future
      Lambillotte: Only question on AVs is timing
      CAR official says EV future brighter than autonomous
    • Biden signs executive order, prioritizes U.S.-made EVs, PPE
      Conti starts production of ‘HL' load index tires for select OE customers
      ITC votes to keep duties in place on China P/LT tire imports
      Hankook gains OE fitments on Audi RS Q8
    • Conti starts production of ‘HL' load index tires for select OE customers
      ITC votes to keep duties in place on China P/LT tire imports
      Russia's Kama Tyres expanding truck, ag tire capacities
      Hankook gains OE fitments on Audi RS Q8
    • DuPont investing in Liveo line of silicone products
      A change at the top for Stockwell Elastomerics
      Flexan receives FDA registration for Suzhou facility
      63rd Polyurethanes Technical Conference set for fall
    • Phillips Carbon Black expanding capacity at site in India
      DuPont investing in Liveo line of silicone products
      New systems solutions advance the sustainability of automotive weatherseals
      Arburg: 2021 Technology Days in June will run for 6 days
    • DuPont investing in Liveo line of silicone products
      A change at the top for Stockwell Elastomerics
      Flexan receives FDA registration for Suzhou facility
      Coi Rubber adding on to plant in China
    • WCCO task force navigates pandemic, expands communications
      ASTM cancels April meetings as COVID-19 continues impact
      Paycheck Protection Program funding reopens Jan. 15
      Detroit Auto Show canceled; alternative event being planned for September
    • A change at the top for Stockwell Elastomerics
      Angelos Papadimitriou to leave position with Pirelli after six months on job
      Tero Peltomaki named Cimcorp CEO
      Synthomer CEO MacLean to step down by early 2022
    • Biden signs executive order, prioritizes U.S.-made EVs, PPE
      ITC votes to keep duties in place on China P/LT tire imports
      Hwa Fong joins Taiwan tire makers' bid for alternative to import duties
      NLRB certifies USW as bargaining unit for Kumho Tire plant in Georgia
    • Editorial: Against a backdrop of turmoil, M&A deals give glimpse of normalcy
      Column: Pandemic looms over everything in life, business in 2020
      Column: Lessons from the 2020 Best Places to Work
      Editorial: Silicone hit hard by pandemic, expected to bounce back
    • Advancements in synchronous drive belt design for industrial and consumer markets
      Effects of multiple repurposed materials for reinforcements of standard rubber compounds
      Impact of peroxide blends on the cure rate and aged properties in HNBR
      Techniques to detect long chain branching in polymers
    • Rubber Division seeks abstracts for 200th Technical Meeting
      WORD panelists say evolution, authenticity keys to success
      IEC keynote: Communication key to logistics
      IEC speaker: Specialized elastomers may reduce spread of life-threatening pathogens
    • WORD panelists say evolution, authenticity keys to success
      New video celebrates women in rubber industry
      ITEC panelists say women can thrive in tire industry
      Rubber Division planning second Women of Rubber event
    • Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      Faster Access to Your Polymer Compounding Experts Around the World
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      Take a walk thru a HEXPOL Lab
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      HEXPOL offers a unique selection of High Performance Elastomers to match your application requirements
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      It’s what you can’t see that makes the Difference at HEXPOL
  • Blogs
    • Products
    • Wacky World of Rubber
    • New Products: Nova thinks outside the box with sealing tech
      New Products: MonTech introduces 1,500 kN lab press
      New products: 3M introduces new durable, pliable medical adhesive
      New Products: Lanxess launches energy-efficient PU elastomer
    • Wacky World of Rubber: How Trelleborg, teens sealed a spot in the world record book
      Wacky World of Rubber: Of chicken and feet, but not chicken feet
      Wacky World of Rubber: Time to go mattress shopping
      Wacky World of Rubber: Because nothing says football like 'frunk' shrimp
  • Newsletters
    • Rubber in Automotive
    • Silicone News
    • Latex News
    • Sign Up for Newsletters
    • Biden signs executive order, prioritizes U.S.-made EVs, PPE
      Conti starts production of ‘HL' load index tires for select OE customers
      ITC votes to keep duties in place on China P/LT tire imports
      Hankook gains OE fitments on Audi RS Q8
    • DuPont investing in Liveo line of silicone products
      A change at the top for Stockwell Elastomerics
      Flexan receives FDA registration for Suzhou facility
      Coi Rubber adding on to plant in China
    • Bridgestone bets on guayule as alternative natural rubber source
      Synthomer CEO MacLean to step down by early 2022
      Jack Murphy joins Akron Dispersions
      Synthomer optimistic, raises earnings forecast
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • Photo Galleries
  • Directory
  • Resources
    • Classifieds & Mold Mart
    • Sponsored Content
    • White Papers
    • Sponsored By HB Chemical
      The Company Behind the Inventory
      Sponsored By French Oil Mill Machinery
      Process Improvement, Cost Reduction with Custom Press Systems
    • Sponsored By Uncountable Inc.
      Cooper Standard deploys lab informatics platform to synchronize R&D
      Sponsored By Elkem
      LSR Select™: A solution to improve your financial impact in molding applications
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      Peroxide Cureable Silicone Injection Molding
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      Understanding and Selecting Performance Additives for Rubber Compounding
  • Data
  • Events
    • RPN Events
    • RPN Livestreams/Webinars
    • Industry Events
    • Past Events
    • ITEC Library
    • International Silicone Conference Library
    • 2021 Healthcare Elastomers Virtual Edition
      2021 Rubber in Automotive Virtual Edition
      2022 ITEC
  • Advertise
  • DIGITAL EDITION
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. News
August 13, 2018 02:00 AM

Trump CAFE proposal faces legal thicket

Eric Kulisch
Automotive News
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print

    WASHINGTON—For the federal government's proposed freeze of the Corporate Average Fuel Economy Standard to prevail, Trump administration officials will have to win on the legal battlefield.

    Already, waves of opponents—from state and local governments, to safety, consumer, energy conservation and environmental interests—are mobilizing for an all-out assault to kill the Trump administration's proposal, which would reduce the average fuel economy target for cars and light-duty trucks from an estimated 46.8 mpg for the 2025 model year and freeze it at the 2020 level of 37 mpg.

    An equally tough skirmish will revolve around the administration's plan to rescind California's authority under the 1970 Clean Air Act to set stricter emissions and efficiency standards than federal agencies. Under an agreement engineered by President Obama in 2012, California recognized the federal standard as equivalent to its own.

    While auto makers pressed the Trump administration for more flexibility under the 2012 agreement, they have voiced concern about a protracted legal battle that would throw product development plans off track or upset the alignment between U.S. and California rules.

    Environmental lawyers say the Trump administration could have difficulty convincing judges of its authority to weaken fuel economy standards or the merits of the decision itself. Still, legal gray areas cloud how cases could be decided.

    The government "is going to have to justify to a court why it's changing its position, because the rule was put in place after a robust administrative process and record" showed its benefits, said Cara Horowitz, co-director of the Emmett Institute on Climate Change and the Environment at the UCLA School of law. "It's often harder to justify a changing of a position than the taking of a position, because you have to overcome the presumption that the rule was right in the first place."

    Attorneys general from California and a dozen states that follow its clean-car program have threatened to challenge the weaker standards. States already are fighting the initial decision to reopen the Obama administration's determination that the plan's original feasibility assumptions were appropriate.

    One line of attack from clean-car supporters will be that the Obama administration's rule—finalized in January 2017, a week before President Trump took office, and more than a year ahead of the target date—was legally binding.

    "Does the EPA get a second bite at the apple?" said Mark LeBel, a staff attorney at the Acadia Center, a clean-energy advocacy group in the Northeast. "There's a provision in the regulations that established the standards for a midterm review, but there's no provision for revisiting a midterm review."

    Under the Administrative Procedure Act, attorneys say, the administration also would have to show that its decision to rewrite the standard wasn't arbitrary or capricious.

    Checking the math

    States and interest groups are expected to attack the rule's rationale by comparing the Trump and Obama administrations' evidence, aiming to show the decision was politically motivated. The role played by the EPA's scientific and technical staff will be in the spotlight.

    "Courts are generally deferential to agency expertise, but they are looking for things that could qualify as obvious errors or things that smack of motivated reasoning that looks as if the agency isn't applying expertise in an evenhanded way, but is sort of cooking the books," LeBel said.

    "And the Trump administration has not shown that it's super thorough when it comes to crossing all its T's and dotting its I's."

    Last week, a federal appeals court ordered the EPA to ban a common pesticide associated with developmental disabilities, overruling former EPA chief Scott Pruitt, who rejected recommendations by agency scientists that it be removed from the market.

    Internal agency emails published by The New York Times also show that EPA political appointees advanced more flexible rules regarding the use of asbestos, a carcinogen, over the objections of EPA scientists.

    'The kitchen sink'

    For the proposed fuel economy rule, stakeholders will use the 60-day public comment period to lay the groundwork for their legal challenges, said Maureen Gorsen, a partner in Alston & Bird's environmental practice. And groups will coordinate arguments submitted to the EPA and NHTSA.

    "We are going to see the kitchen sink," she said. "They'll launch everything in that administrative record that they might possibly think they might need in litigation."

    Potential litigants, Gorsen added, will review everything in the record and start prioritizing arguments that are most likely to prevail in court.

    How the EPA would go about revoking California's waiver is unclear. The Clean Air Act doesn't specify such a process, and it has never been tried. Over five decades, California has received more than 100 waivers. One covers the entire advanced clean-car program, including regulations on tailpipe emissions of particulate matter and greenhouse gases and the zero-emission vehicle mandate.

    The EPA is likely to argue that since it can grant authority, it inherently has the power to take it away. The proposal argues that California's waiver is unlawful because a 1970s energy conservation law that established fuel-efficiency standards reserves those powers for NHTSA.

    California gained its waivers on the "compelling and extraordinary circumstances" test because major urban areas have some of the worst smog in the nation and fail to meet EPA standards. The Emmett Institute's Horowitz said the Trump administration likely will argue that those circumstances no longer exist, if they ever did, and that climate change is not unique to California.

    Environmentalists say the state's long drought and fierce wildfires prove that climate change is having an outsize impact on California.

    Horowitz said states and interest groups have a strong case because lower courts have twice rejected the argument that the NHTSA provision bars states from regulating carbon emissions from vehicles.

    "I think the Trump administration is going to try and put as high a bar as they can on California and say that unless California itself is solving climate change, then [the regulations] are not doing any good," LeBel said.

    "California will claim they are facing hardships," he added. "So, they will try to set different standards for each other, and it's not clear where the courts would come down on that."

    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Rubber & Plastics News wants to hear from its readers. If you want to express your opinion on a story or issue, email your letter to Editor Bruce Meyer at [email protected].

    SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTERS
    EMAIL ADDRESS

    Please enter a valid email address.

    Please enter your email address.

    Please verify captcha.

    Please select at least one newsletter to subscribe.

    Get our newsletters

    Staying current is easy with Rubber & Plastics News delivered straight to your inbox, free of charge.

    Subscribe Today

    Subscribe to Rubber & Plastics News to get the best coverage and leading insights in the industry.

    SUBSCRIBE
    Connect with Us
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Twitter

    MISSION

    To serve companies in the global rubber product industry by delivering news, industry insights, opinions and technical information.

    web
    Contact Us

    2291 Riverfront Pkwy, Suite 1000
    Cuyahoga Falls,
    OH 44221

    Customer Service:
    877-320-1726

    Resources
    • About Us
    • Digital Edition
    • Contact the Staff
    • Advertise
    • Order Reprints
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Request
    • Terms of Service
    • Careers
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Partner Sites
    • Tire Business
    • European Rubber Journal
    • Plastics News
    • Plastics News China
    • Urethanes Technology
    • Automotive News
    • Crain Brands
    Copyright © 1996-2021. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • News
      • ITEC
      • Automotive
      • Tire
      • Non-Tire
      • Suppliers
      • Silicone
      • Latex
      • Coronavirus
      • Executive Action
      • Government/Legal
      • Opinion
      • Technical Notebooks
      • International Elastomer Show
      • Women in Tire & Rubber
      • HEXPOL Sponsored Content
    • Blogs
      • Products
      • Wacky World of Rubber
    • Newsletters
      • Rubber in Automotive
      • Silicone News
      • Latex News
      • Sign Up for Newsletters
    • Multimedia
      • Videos
      • Photo Galleries
    • Directory
    • Resources
      • Classifieds & Mold Mart
      • Sponsored Content
      • White Papers
    • Data
    • Events
      • RPN Events
      • RPN Livestreams/Webinars
      • Industry Events
      • Past Events
      • ITEC Library
      • International Silicone Conference Library
    • Advertise
    • DIGITAL EDITION