Skip to main content
Sister Publication Links
  • European Rubber Journal
  • Plastics News
web
Subscribe
  • Login
  • Register
  • Subscribe
  • News
    • ITEC
    • Automotive
    • Tire
    • Non-Tire
    • Suppliers
    • Silicone
    • Latex
    • Coronavirus
    • Executive Action
    • Government/Legal
    • Opinion
    • Technical Notebooks
    • International Elastomer Show
    • Women in Tire & Rubber
    • HEXPOL Sponsored Content
    • Goodyear recognized by Lockheed Martin as 'elite supplier'
      EV tire advancements to help secure future
      Lambillotte: Only question on AVs is timing
      CAR official says EV future brighter than autonomous
    • Motion Industries rebrands as 'Motion'
      USW opposes Taiwan tire makers' dumping counterproposal
      Goodyear-branded transmission belts set to return
      Hot topics at virtual CES: AVs, air taxis and drones
    • USW opposes Taiwan tire makers' dumping counterproposal
      Greenergy, Haldor Topsoe tech turns tires to fuel
      India decides against extending carbon black duties
      GRI expanding ag tire capacity at 3-year-old Sri Lanka plant
    • Motion Industries rebrands as 'Motion'
      Proto Labs to buy e-commerce company 3D Hubs for $280 million
      NewAge Industries celebrates 15 years of employee ownership
      India decides against extending carbon black duties
    • Tero Peltomaki named Cimcorp CEO
      Nynas expects to be stronger after reorganization
      Synthomer CEO MacLean to step down by early 2022
      Safic-Alcan and Arkema working together on distribution deal
    • Proto Labs to buy e-commerce company 3D Hubs for $280 million
      Ace Products & Consulting partners with Wallace Instruments
      Safic-Alcan extends distribution agreement with Momentive
      Momentive aims to grow silicone presence in Asia-Pacific region
    • WCCO task force navigates pandemic, expands communications
      ASTM cancels April meetings as COVID-19 continues impact
      Paycheck Protection Program funding reopens Jan. 15
      Detroit Auto Show canceled; alternative event being planned for September
    • Tero Peltomaki named Cimcorp CEO
      Synthomer CEO MacLean to step down by early 2022
      ARP Materials adds technical sales manager
      Jack Murphy joins Akron Dispersions
    • USW opposes Taiwan tire makers' dumping counterproposal
      India decides against extending carbon black duties
      Hot topics at virtual CES: AVs, air taxis and drones
      Paycheck Protection Program funding reopens Jan. 15
    • Column: Pandemic looms over everything in life, business in 2020
      Column: Lessons from the 2020 Best Places to Work
      Editorial: Silicone hit hard by pandemic, expected to bounce back
      Column: Still far way from normal
    • Advancements in synchronous drive belt design for industrial and consumer markets
      Effects of multiple repurposed materials for reinforcements of standard rubber compounds
      Impact of peroxide blends on the cure rate and aged properties in HNBR
      Techniques to detect long chain branching in polymers
    • Rubber Division seeks abstracts for 200th Technical Meeting
      WORD panelists say evolution, authenticity keys to success
      IEC keynote: Communication key to logistics
      IEC speaker: Specialized elastomers may reduce spread of life-threatening pathogens
    • WORD panelists say evolution, authenticity keys to success
      New video celebrates women in rubber industry
      ITEC panelists say women can thrive in tire industry
      Rubber Division planning second Women of Rubber event
    • Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      Faster Access to Your Polymer Compounding Experts Around the World
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      Take a walk thru a HEXPOL Lab
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      HEXPOL offers a unique selection of High Performance Elastomers to match your application requirements
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      It’s what you can’t see that makes the Difference at HEXPOL
  • Blogs
    • Products
    • Wacky World of Rubber
    • New Products: Nova thinks outside the box with sealing tech
      New Products: MonTech introduces 1,500 kN lab press
      New products: 3M introduces new durable, pliable medical adhesive
      New Products: Lanxess launches energy-efficient PU elastomer
    • Wacky World of Rubber: How Trelleborg, teens sealed a spot in the world record book
      Wacky World of Rubber: Of chicken and feet, but not chicken feet
      Wacky World of Rubber: Time to go mattress shopping
      Wacky World of Rubber: Because nothing says football like 'frunk' shrimp
  • Newsletters
    • Rubber in Automotive
    • Silicone News
    • Latex News
    • Sign Up for Newsletters
    • Motion Industries rebrands as 'Motion'
      USW opposes Taiwan tire makers' dumping counterproposal
      Goodyear-branded transmission belts set to return
      Hot topics at virtual CES: AVs, air taxis and drones
    • Proto Labs to buy e-commerce company 3D Hubs for $280 million
      Ace Products & Consulting partners with Wallace Instruments
      Safic-Alcan extends distribution agreement with Momentive
      Momentive aims to grow silicone presence in Asia-Pacific region
    • Bridgestone bets on guayule as alternative natural rubber source
      Synthomer CEO MacLean to step down by early 2022
      Jack Murphy joins Akron Dispersions
      Synthomer optimistic, raises earnings forecast
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • Photo Galleries
  • Directory
  • Resources
    • Classifieds & Mold Mart
    • Sponsored Content
    • White Papers
    • Sponsored By HB Chemical
      The Company Behind the Inventory
      Sponsored By French Oil Mill Machinery
      Process Improvement, Cost Reduction with Custom Press Systems
    • Sponsored By Uncountable Inc.
      Cooper Standard deploys lab informatics platform to synchronize R&D
      Sponsored By Elkem
      LSR Select™: A solution to improve your financial impact in molding applications
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      Peroxide Cureable Silicone Injection Molding
      Sponsored By HEXPOL Compounding
      Understanding and Selecting Performance Additives for Rubber Compounding
  • Data
  • Events
    • RPN Events
    • RPN Livestreams/Webinars
    • Industry Events
    • Past Events
    • ITEC Library
    • International Silicone Conference Library
    • 2021 Healthcare Elastomers Virtual Edition
      2021 Rubber in Automotive Virtual Edition
      2020 International Silicone Conference Virtual Edition
      2020 ITEC Virtual Edition
  • Advertise
  • DIGITAL EDITION
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. News
March 28, 2014 02:00 AM

EPDM group challenges finding of roofing study

Chris Sweeney
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print
    Workers install a Firestone RubberGard R.M.A. System, an EPDM roof. Firestone, like most of its fellow members of the EPDM Roofing Association, makes both EDPM and TPO roof membranes.

    BETHESDA, Md.—The EPDM Roofing Association is challenging a study conducted by Lawrence Berkley National Laboratory, which recommends policy makers phase out black EPDM roof membranes because they pose a public health risk.

    The LBNL's study, “Economic comparison of white, green, and black flat roofs in the United States,” compared black, white and green roofs during a 50-year analysis to see which of the three is the most cost-effective.

    LBNL took 22 case studies—some are averages of multiple roofs and projects—that consisted of some form of energy savings data. To qualify for the LBNL's study, the case study must compare some combination of these three roofing types.

    LBNL ultimately concluded that both white and black roofs were significantly more cost-effective than green. White did not beat out black by a large margin—resulting in a net savings of just $2.40 per square foot over 50 years.

    Despite stating its study is purely an economic comparison, the LBNL recommended in its discussion section that “the fact that the large public health advantages of green or white roofs over black roofs cannot be incorporated into an economic analysis indicates that private actors will not always make the socially optimal roofing choice. This presents a strong case for public policy to intervene by phasing out black roofs in locations with hot summers.”

    The ERA—whose membership includes Firestone Building Products, Carlisle Syntec and Johns Manville Inc., producers of both white and black roofing membranes—takes exception to that.

    “That blew us away,” said Mike DuCharme, director of product marketing at Carlisle Syntec. “We went back and reviewed a New England Journal of Medicine article, and there is no mention of black or white roofs in it. In our review of that article, we found that it indicated seniors or disabled folks would be more impacted by a heat wave. That article recommended precautions be taken in looking after seniors and the disabled during a heat wave.”

    The article the ERA reviewed was the same article cited in the LBNL's study—”Heat-related deaths during the July 1995 heat wave in Chicago”—to support its health risks claim. The LBNL also cited a study examining a 2003 heat wave in Europe. However, neither study examines or concludes that the roof membrane played a roll in the deaths resulting from either heat wave.

    The New England Journal of Medicine article said more than half of the victims it examined lived on the top floor of a building, but did not specify the type of building or roof membrane. When the article was cited in the LBNL's study, it included a parenthetical “beneath a black roof” in a footnote.

    Ben Mandel—research assistant at LBNL, and one author of the study—said in 1995 nearly all apartment buildings in Chicago and the U.S. had black roofs.

    “It's not explicitly stated that black roofs were a cause of death, and we wouldn't say that either, but it doesn't take too much of a logical leap to understand that the darker the roof is, the more sunlight it absorbs, the more heat it's going to conduct into the space below it,” Mandel said.

    The ERA also claims that evidence supporting black roofs went largely ignored in the LBNL's study—specifically the heating penalty for a white roof in winter climates. While white membranes offer cooling benefits in the summer, the ERA said that much of that is offset by a heating penalty in the winter.

    While Mandel said the heating penalty would not completely counter the cooling benefits, he acknowledged that this was an area the study could expand upon.

    He said the reason the penalty was not included was because the case studies they examined did not report those figures in their analysis.

    “It would definitely make it closer to parity, there is no question,” Mandel said. “That is something we had hoped to include in the paper. I think that's definitely fair game for future research to find a fair value.”

    DuCharme said that in the ERA's analysis, the group found that the roofs the LBNL selected were largely anecdotal. In his review of the data, he noted the study had some EPDM roofs costing as high as $24 per square foot and some white roofs as low as 20 cents per square foot, which he described as “insane.”

    “Twenty-two roofs, even if they were very scientifically collected, would not be adequate,” DuCharme said. “If they had 100 or 200 roofs, that would start to smooth out some of the bias. And they would have to do that in different geographies with different roof system types.”

    Most ERA members manufacture both roof membranes, and DuCharme said the organization is trying to steer the market away from a single-component solution. Usually, ERA members are selling an entire roof system, not just the membrane. He said energy efficiencies will be impacted by the air barrier and the insulation in addition to the roof membrane, not from just one element of the roof.

    “Most of us have a foot in both sides of the camp, so we're large producers of white and black membranes,” DuCharme said. “I think we have a pretty balanced outlook on this, but this study is just so biased overall. It really got our radar up and made us dig substantially deeper.”

    Related Articles
    Firestone Building Products to acquire Spanish EPDM plant
    Roofing group champions EPDM
    Raising the roof issue: EPDM vs. TPO It's more than just a black, white debate
    Rubber roofing still has legs
    Carlisle makes progress on fifth TPO line
    ERA makes recommendation to EPA on environmental guidelines
    Carlisle Companies reports strong second quarter results
    Roofing delegates to present at Waterproof Membranes Conference
    Roofing group selects first female chair
    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Rubber & Plastics News wants to hear from its readers. If you want to express your opinion on a story or issue, email your letter to Editor Bruce Meyer at [email protected].

    SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTERS
    EMAIL ADDRESS

    Please enter a valid email address.

    Please enter your email address.

    Please verify captcha.

    Please select at least one newsletter to subscribe.

    Get our newsletters

    Staying current is easy with Rubber & Plastics News delivered straight to your inbox, free of charge.

    Subscribe Today

    Subscribe to Rubber & Plastics News to get the best coverage and leading insights in the industry.

    SUBSCRIBE
    Connect with Us
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Twitter

    MISSION

    To serve companies in the global rubber product industry by delivering news, industry insights, opinions and technical information.

    web
    Contact Us

    2291 Riverfront Pkwy, Suite 1000
    Cuyahoga Falls,
    OH 44221

    Customer Service:
    877-320-1726

    Resources
    • About Us
    • Digital Edition
    • Contact the Staff
    • Advertise
    • Order Reprints
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Request
    • Terms of Service
    • Careers
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Partner Sites
    • Tire Business
    • European Rubber Journal
    • Plastics News
    • Plastics News China
    • Urethanes Technology
    • Automotive News
    • Crain Brands
    Copyright © 1996-2021. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • News
      • ITEC
      • Automotive
      • Tire
      • Non-Tire
      • Suppliers
      • Silicone
      • Latex
      • Coronavirus
      • Executive Action
      • Government/Legal
      • Opinion
      • Technical Notebooks
      • International Elastomer Show
      • Women in Tire & Rubber
      • HEXPOL Sponsored Content
    • Blogs
      • Products
      • Wacky World of Rubber
    • Newsletters
      • Rubber in Automotive
      • Silicone News
      • Latex News
      • Sign Up for Newsletters
    • Multimedia
      • Videos
      • Photo Galleries
    • Directory
    • Resources
      • Classifieds & Mold Mart
      • Sponsored Content
      • White Papers
    • Data
    • Events
      • RPN Events
      • RPN Livestreams/Webinars
      • Industry Events
      • Past Events
      • ITEC Library
      • International Silicone Conference Library
    • Advertise
    • DIGITAL EDITION