Skip to main content
Sister Publication Links
  • European Rubber Journal
  • Plastics News
  • Tire Business
web
Subscribe
  • Login
  • Register
  • Subscribe
  • News
    • Automotive
    • Tire
    • Non-Tire
    • Suppliers
    • Silicone
    • Latex
    • Coronavirus
    • Executive Action
    • Government/Legal
    • Opinion
    • Technical Notebooks
    • Women in Tire & Rubber
    • ITEC
    • International Elastomer Show
    • GM, Ford join businesses urging Biden to at least halve U.S. emissions by 2030
      ETRMA reports 'encouraging' signs in European tire markets
      Staria people mover previews Hyundai's approach to new mobility era
      Hutchinson on board Perseverance Mars Rover
    • Nanotechnology coming of age: Between new and legacy industries, time for tiny tech is now
      ETRMA reports 'encouraging' signs in European tire markets
      Orion's sustainability focus built into everyday business
      Bridgestone part of Louisiana environmental cleanup settlement
    • Orion's sustainability focus built into everyday business
      Rahco Rubber overcoming challenges with a family-first attitude
      Rubber Division's May educational schedule set
      Tamsin Astor to join Rubber Division's WORD Conversations
    • ECHA advances controversial EU silicone feedstock proposals
      Nanotechnology coming of age: Between new and legacy industries, time for tiny tech is now
      Orion's sustainability focus built into everyday business
      Pickups taking bigger hits from microchip shortage
    • ECHA advances controversial EU silicone feedstock proposals
      Smithers ramps up with Suzhou testing facility
      5 for 50: Bruce Meyer's five most memorable work trips
      AirBoss unveiling high heat-resistant EPDM
    • ‘China-only Chinaplas' opens as first major industry show in the pandemic
      Latin America faces tough recovery from COVID-19, KraussMaffei executive says
      Titan Tire to offer free COVID-19 vaccines at Iowa facility
      Bridgestone hosts vaccination events for plant employees
    • Detroit 3 execs join voting rights debate in Michigan
      Harwick Standard hires Marc Pignataro to executive role
      Motion Industries promotes industry veteran Jim May
      Hutchinson names new chairman, CEO
    • ECHA advances controversial EU silicone feedstock proposals
      GM, Ford join businesses urging Biden to at least halve U.S. emissions by 2030
      Bridgestone part of Louisiana environmental cleanup settlement
      Biden's infrastructure proposal could boost transition to EVs, AVs
    • Meyer: Sunflowers seek their due
      OUR VIEW: Big ideas power big technological leaps
      Column: Ramping up to an RPN milestone
      Our view: It may be time to rethink, rebuild supply chains
    • Correlating cure kinetics and physical properties with accelerator variations in a model SBR compound
      Material to give tire compounds lower density, lower hysteresis and improved wear
      Technical notebook: How to control porosity in extruded EPDM dense profile
      Part 2: Studying RPA ASTM methods for detecting compound quality differences
    • Tamsin Astor to join Rubber Division's WORD Conversations
      WORD Conversations: Charles Goodyear Medalist Puskas says academia needs to ease time commitments
      Women find success, opportunity in petrochemicals
      Rubber Division to host WORD webinar series
    • Goodyear recognized by Lockheed Martin as 'elite supplier'
      EV tire advancements to help secure future
      Lambillotte: Only question on AVs is timing
      CAR official says EV future brighter than autonomous
    • Rubber Division preparing for Spring Technical Meeting
      Rubber Division introduces WORD webinar series
      Rubber Division seeks abstracts for 200th Technical Meeting
      WORD panelists say evolution, authenticity keys to success
  • Blogs
    • Products
    • Wacky World of Rubber
    • New Products: Birla Carbon showcases two new carbon blacks
      New Products: MonTech adds to LP 3000 lab press lineup with custom options
      New Products: 3M rolls out new silicone adhesive for medical use
      GRI gains OE fitment for KION Group forklifts
    • Wacky World of Rubber: How Trelleborg, teens sealed a spot in the world record book
      Wacky World of Rubber: Of chicken and feet, but not chicken feet
      Wacky World of Rubber: Time to go mattress shopping
      Wacky World of Rubber: Because nothing says football like 'frunk' shrimp
  • Newsletters
    • Rubber in Automotive
    • Silicone News
    • Latex News
    • Sign Up for Newsletters
    • GM, Ford join businesses urging Biden to at least halve U.S. emissions by 2030
      ETRMA reports 'encouraging' signs in European tire markets
      Staria people mover previews Hyundai's approach to new mobility era
      Hutchinson on board Perseverance Mars Rover
    • ECHA advances controversial EU silicone feedstock proposals
      Smithers ramps up with Suzhou testing facility
      5 for 50: Bruce Meyer's five most memorable work trips
      AirBoss unveiling high heat-resistant EPDM
    • Zeon integrates rubber and latex divisions
      Meyer: Sunflowers seek their due
      World Rubber Summit to be virtual this year
      Synthomer launches Asia innovation center in Malaysia
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • Photo Galleries
  • Directory
  • Resources
    • Classifieds & Mold Mart
    • Sponsored Content
    • White Papers
    • HB Chemical
      Sponsored By HB Chemical
      The HB Chemical and Ravago Partnership: Taking Customer Service to a New Level
      Sponsored By HB Chemical
      Above and Beyond with HB Chemical
      Sponsored By HB Chemical
      The Company Behind the Inventory
      Sponsored By French Oil Mill Machinery
      Process Improvement, Cost Reduction with Custom Press Systems
    • Sponsored By AirBoss
      AirBoss introduces next-gen EPDM compound: HeatBoss EPDM
      Sponsored By Uncountable Inc.
      Labs of the Future: How to Choose a Laboratory Information Management System in 2021
      Sponsored By Uncountable Inc.
      Cooper Standard deploys lab informatics platform to synchronize R&D
      Sponsored By Elkem
      LSR Select™: A solution to improve your financial impact in molding applications
  • Data
  • Events
    • RPN Events
    • RPN Livestreams/Webinars
    • Industry Events
    • Past Events
    • ITEC Library
    • International Silicone Conference Library
    • 2021 Healthcare Elastomers Virtual Edition
      2021 Rubber in Automotive Virtual Edition
      2021 International Latex Conference Virtual Edition
      2022 ITEC
  • Advertise
  • DIGITAL EDITION
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. News
November 18, 2013 01:00 AM

Apollo lands first punch in merger battle with Cooper

Miles Moore
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print

    WILMINGTON, Del.—Apollo Tyres Ltd. won the first battle, but its war with Cooper Tire & Rubber Co. is far from over.

    On Nov. 8, the day after a three-day trial before the Delaware Chancery Court, Judge Sam Glasscock III made a partial bench ruling that Apollo had not breached the terms of its merger agreement with Cooper by asking for a purchase price that would shave at least $2.50 per share from the $2.5 billion deal, and perhaps as much as $9.

    Four days later, Cooper announced it would appeal Glasscock's decision before the Delaware Supreme Court.

    It remains to be settled whether Apollo tried to renege on a $35-per-share merger deal with Cooper, or if the U.S. tire maker forced Apollo to ask for a lower per-share price by misrepresenting its earnings outlook and ties with its Chinese subsidiary.

    "Cooper entered into the agreement with Apollo in a position of strength," the Findlay, Ohio-based tire maker said in a press release.

    Cooper generated record profits in 2012 and the first quarter of 2013, and operating profit was up in the first six months of 2013 compared with the same period in 2012, Cooper said. This was what attracted Apollo to make a bid for Cooper, the company said.

    In its own statement, Apollo said it was pleased with Glasscock's ruling.

    "The court found that Apollo had used "reasonable best efforts' to negotiate with the United Steelworkers union and that, contrary to Cooper's claims, "nothing in Apollo's conduct indicates buyer's remorse,' " Apollo said.

    In a letter dated Nov. 9, the day after he issued his bench verdict, Glasscock said Cooper had until Nov. 14 to maintain its right to compel Apollo to complete the merger.

    Third-quarter results delayed

    Continuing problems at Chengshan (Shandong) Tire Co. Ltd. (CCT), Cooper's Chinese joint venture with Chengshan Group Co. Ltd., made it difficult for Cooper to issue its third-quarter financial report by Nov. 14. Cooper Chief Financial Officer Bradley Hughes testified to this in court Nov. 5.

    But if the third-quarter results did not come out by then, Cooper will not be entitled thereafter to compel the merger, Glasscock said in his letter.

    On Nov. 12, Cooper filed a document with the Securities and Exchange Commission, informing the SEC that the third-quarter results would have to be delayed until CCT provides necessary information to allow their completion.

    Cooper said it seeks not only "specific performance" of the merger (i.e. an order compelling Apollo to complete the deal exactly according to the negotiated terms) but also a declaration regarding the parties' rights and obligations under the merger agreement, which the Chancery Court has not yet decided.

    "While an inability to issue third-quarter results might affect the availability of the current financing, it does not provide Apollo with any ground for avoiding its obligations under the merger agreement," Cooper said.

    "The court's ruling made clear that Apollo has to use its reasonable best efforts to close the remaining conditions," it said.

    For its part, Apollo said it doesn't agree with Cooper that the proposed merger caused Cooper's lack of control over CCT.

    "Cooper is again attempting to avoid rather than accept its responsibility for the situation at CCT, as it has done throughout this process," Apollo said.

    Points of contention

    Cooper filed its suit with the Chancery Court Oct. 4, seeking specific performance of the $2.5 billion merger agreement reached June 12.

    In the absence of specific performance, Cooper sought financial compensation for all losses it sustained from the merger, along with attorneys' fees and court costs.

    Cooper accused Apollo of a "knowing, deliberate, and material breach of the merger agreement." In reply, Apollo said, "Cooper is seeking prematurely and without claim of right to specifically enforce the merger agreement before it has satisfied the closing conditions and while it itself is in material breach of the merger agreement."

    Among the major points of contention were:

    • Whether Apollo deliberately delayed making an agreement with the USW and sought to get the per-share price of Cooper's stock reduced based on an unrealistic estimate of the cost of such an agreement;

    • Whether Cooper misrepresented its long-term financial outlook to Apollo during merger negotiations; and

    • Whether Cooper downplayed the likelihood of strife with CCT based on Chengshan's disapproval of the merger.

    At the Nov. 5 court hearing, Cooper CEO Roy V. Armes testified about a Sept. 25, 2013 telephone conversation with Apollo's vice chairman, whom he said estimated the cost of a deal with the USW at $75 million-$125 million.

    "It was clear he wanted a price reduction," Armes said. "I could not negotiate an agreement, then turn around and ask my shareholders to pay for it."

    In further questioning, Armes said he knew Apollo's estimates were high because Cooper recently had settled a dispute with the USW for considerably less.

    In his Nov. 5 testimony, Hughes acknowledged that Cooper's second-quarter earnings were less than originally projected.

    The final figures were released shortly after the merger was announced, and Apollo said the earlier projections influenced its decision to agree to the merger.

    Hughes quoted one of his former supervisors at Ford Motor Co.: "The one thing you know is that the forecast is going to be wrong."

    Hughes blamed short-term issues with the startup of Cooper's new Enterprise Resource Policy system for the shortfall, as well as pricing issues, the tire industry's competitive environment and costs associated with the merger. He insisted, however, that Cooper gave Apollo sufficient notice of these problems.

    "I'm surprised they were surprised," he said.

    In their questioning of Hughes, Apollo attorneys quoted Cooper documents telling Apollo that acquiring Cooper was "a low-cost way of Apollo entering the Chinese market."

    Instead, according to court documents, union workers at CCT, encouraged by management, went on strike June 21. Chengshan Group, according to Cooper, wanted to place its own bid on Cooper.

    Although Cooper owns 65 percent of CCT, the Chinese company no longer manufactures Cooper-brand tires, according to Hughes. Cooper executives also are barred from the CCT plant, he said, except for Chief Technology Officer Kurt Reid and a few others.

    Cooper's executive committee has approved a policy of not paying suppliers for future shipments to CCT, according to Hughes. "We thought that might encourage them to be more cooperative," he said.

    The merger's future

    Despite the lawsuit, Apollo said it is still interested in proceeding with the merger.

    "We remain committed to finding a sensible way forward for all affected stakeholders, including the USW, and look forward to seeing Cooper's updated financials when available," the company said.

    Cooper, however, is adamant about proceeding only under the original terms of the agreement.

    The outside date for completion of the merger is Dec. 31 of this year, Cooper said. "If the failure to close by that date is caused by Apollo's breach, it cannot terminate the merger agreement even then," it said. "If the financing becomes unavailable, Apollo has obligations to secure alternative financing."

    After Glasscock's decision, Cooper's shares fell 11.5 percent on the New York Stock Exchange. On Nov. 12, however, Apollo reported a 44 percent increase in its net profit in its second quarter.

    Related Articles
    Cooper's Armes: It was clear Apollo wanted price reduction
    Apollo 'pleased' with judge's ruling in case against Cooper
    Cooper appeals decision of Delaware court in Apollo lawsuit
    Apollo reports double-digit growth in operating, net income
    Cooper tells SEC third-quarter financial results will be late
    Cooper signs agreement with Elio Motors
    Delaware court grants Cooper's motion for expedited review
    Cooper, Apollo deal devolves quickly from idyllic start
    Cooper workers overwhelmingly approve revised contract
    Cooper pursues damages in dispute with Apollo
    Firms spend more time on court trials than product trials
    Shareholders up in arms, file suit against Cooper
    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Rubber & Plastics News wants to hear from its readers. If you want to express your opinion on a story or issue, email your letter to Editor Bruce Meyer at [email protected].

    SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTERS
    EMAIL ADDRESS

    Please enter a valid email address.

    Please enter your email address.

    Please verify captcha.

    Please select at least one newsletter to subscribe.

    Get our newsletters

    Staying current is easy with Rubber & Plastics News delivered straight to your inbox, free of charge.

    Subscribe Today

    Subscribe to Rubber & Plastics News to get the best coverage and leading insights in the industry.

    SUBSCRIBE
    Connect with Us
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Twitter

    MISSION

    To serve companies in the global rubber product industry by delivering news, industry insights, opinions and technical information.

    web
    Contact Us

    2291 Riverfront Pkwy, Suite 1000
    Cuyahoga Falls,
    OH 44221

    Customer Service:
    877-320-1726

    Resources
    • About Us
    • Digital Edition
    • Contact the Staff
    • Advertise
    • Order Reprints
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Request
    • Terms of Service
    • Careers
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Partner Sites
    • Tire Business
    • European Rubber Journal
    • Plastics News
    • Plastics News China
    • Urethanes Technology
    • Automotive News
    • Crain Brands
    Copyright © 1996-2021. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • News
      • Automotive
      • Tire
      • Non-Tire
      • Suppliers
      • Silicone
      • Latex
      • Coronavirus
      • Executive Action
      • Government/Legal
      • Opinion
      • Technical Notebooks
      • Women in Tire & Rubber
      • ITEC
      • International Elastomer Show
    • Blogs
      • Products
      • Wacky World of Rubber
    • Newsletters
      • Rubber in Automotive
      • Silicone News
      • Latex News
      • Sign Up for Newsletters
    • Multimedia
      • Videos
      • Photo Galleries
    • Directory
    • Resources
      • Classifieds & Mold Mart
      • Sponsored Content
      • White Papers
    • Data
    • Events
      • RPN Events
      • RPN Livestreams/Webinars
      • Industry Events
      • Past Events
      • ITEC Library
      • International Silicone Conference Library
    • Advertise
    • DIGITAL EDITION